Head to head · 2026
Best Friends by Sheri The Original Calming Donut Bed (23" Small) vs Furhaven Orthopedic CertiPUR-US Sofa-Style Dog Bed (Small)
We may earn a commission from Amazon links on this page — at no extra cost to you. How this works
Contender A
The plush donut bed that started a thousand imitations — a raised shag-fur rim your dog can burrow into, curl against, and disappear inside.
~$35 typical price
Buy on AmazonContender B
Real foam support, a three-sided bolster, and a washable cover for the price of a large pizza.
~$30 typical price
Buy on AmazonOur verdict
Two different theories of sleep. The Sheri donut is a raised-rim nest for dogs that curl, burrow, and lean — anxious sleepers and cold-weather curlers adore it, but it's polyfill, not foam. The Furhaven is a flat orthopedic foam couch with bolsters on three sides — better joint support, easier for stiff dogs to walk onto, and the cover comes off for the wash. Watch your dog sleep for a week: curled in a ball, get the donut; sprawled flat, get the Furhaven.
Pick the Best Friends by Sheri if…
- ✓Your dog curls into a ball or burrows under blankets to sleep
- ✓An anxious or rescue dog that settles better with a rim to lean into
- ✓The fur-like fabric and nest shape matter more than foam support
Pick the Furhaven if…
- ✓Your dog sprawls, or is older and needs real foam under the joints
- ✓Low, walk-on entry for short-legged and senior dogs
- ✓You want a fully removable, machine-washable cover
Spec by spec
| Spec | Best Friends by Sheri The Original Calming Donut Bed (23" Small) | Furhaven Orthopedic CertiPUR-US Sofa-Style Dog Bed (Small) |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 9.1 / 10 | 8.6 / 10 |
| Size tested | 23" diameter (Small) | Small (roughly 20" × 15" overall) |
| Fits dogs up to | ~25 lb (a 10–12 lb mini dachshund fits with room to spare) | Small breeds to ~15 lb; a mini dachshund fits well, but measure a long back against the sleep surface |
| Sleep style | Curlers and burrowers; rim doubles as a chin rest | Lean-against sleepers and sprawlers; open front suits stretchers |
| Fill | Loose polyester "AirLoft" fiber fill | — |
| Cover | Faux shag fur (vegan), sewn to the bed | Removable, machine washable (faux fur and suede-style options) |
| Washability | Entire bed machine washable and dryer safe at this size | — |
| Bottom | Water-resistant, non-slip base | — |
| Entry height | Low — the rim compresses, so short-legged dogs step right in | Low front edge — a step-in, not a climb |
| Other sizes | 20" up to 45" for bigger dogs (size up generously) | — |
| Base | — | CertiPUR-US certified foam (egg-crate style on the standard version) |
| Bolsters | — | Three-sided, fiber-filled; front edge stays low for easy entry |
| Foam options | — | Egg-crate, memory foam, or cooling-gel foam at higher tiers |
| Care | — | Wash cover cold and gentle; spot-clean the foam base |
Still deciding?
Read the full reviews for the complete story, or check both current prices — sale pricing swings this class of decision all the time.
~$35 typical price
Buy on Amazon~$30 typical price
Buy on Amazon