Head to head · 2026
Zuke's Mini Naturals Training Treats (Chicken, 1 lb) vs Pupford Freeze-Dried Beef Liver Training Treats (4 oz)
We may earn a commission from Amazon links on this page — at no extra cost to you. How this works
Contender A
Soft, pea-sized, and about 3 calories each — the training treat that lets a 10-pound dog practice a hundred reps without outgrowing the harness.
~$13 typical price
Buy on AmazonContender B
Freeze-dried beef liver bites — 475+ per bag, tiny and potent — the jackpot-tier reward that turns recall training from theoretical to instant.
~$19 typical price
Buy on AmazonOur verdict
The two best training pouches, split by philosophy. Zuke's are soft, pre-sized ~3-calorie pellets — no prep, no crumbs, hundreds of reps per bag, the workhorse for daily sessions. Pupford is freeze-dried liver in 475+ tiny bites — the highest-value flavor most dogs will ever meet at a comparable per-rep calorie cost, and the answer for sensitive stomachs, but it's crumbly and pricier per ounce. Daily obedience reps: Zuke's. Recall training, sensitive stomachs, and 'come NOW' money: Pupford.
Pick the Zuke's if…
- ✓High-rep daily training where per-treat calories decide the budget
- ✓You want a soft treat swallowed instantly, keeping the rep rhythm
- ✓One ingredient list you've already vetted, in six flavors for variety
Pick the Pupford if…
- ✓You need a jackpot-tier reward for recall or reactivity work
- ✓A single-ingredient treat for allergy or elimination-diet households
- ✓You want jackpot flavor in pre-sized bites and don't mind some liver dust
Spec by spec
| Spec | Zuke's Mini Naturals Training Treats (Chicken, 1 lb) | Pupford Freeze-Dried Beef Liver Training Treats (4 oz) |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 9.1 / 10 | 8.9 / 10 |
| Package size | 1 lb pouch (6 oz also available) | 4 oz bag, 475+ bites |
| Flavor | Chicken (peanut butter, salmon, and rabbit also made) | — |
| Calories per treat | About 3 kcal | — |
| Treat size | Pea-sized, roughly the diameter of a fingertip | — |
| Texture | Soft and moist | — |
| First ingredient | Chicken | — |
| Free of | Corn, wheat, and soy | Grains, fillers, preservatives, additives |
| Made in | USA | Sourced and made for Pupford, USA-based brand |
| Best use | High-repetition training and recall rewards | High-value rewards: recall, handling, vet visits, nail trims |
| Ingredients | — | Beef liver, freeze-dried (Pupford's bites keep labels to a bare minimum) |
| Process | — | Freeze-dried raw |
| Piece size | — | Small pre-sized bites, easily crumbled smaller |
| Calories | — | Roughly 1–2 kcal per bite |
| Storage | — | Shelf-stable; reseal the bag |
Still deciding?
Read the full reviews for the complete story, or check both current prices — sale pricing swings this class of decision all the time.
~$13 typical price
Buy on Amazon~$19 typical price
Buy on Amazon