Head to head · 2026
Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew (Small, Bacon) vs Best Bully Sticks 6-Inch All-Natural Bully Sticks
We may earn a commission from Amazon links on this page — at no extra cost to you. How this works
Contender A
A bacon-infused nylon wishbone with paw-friendly ergonomics — the chew that outlasts everything else in the toy bin.
~$13 typical price
Buy on AmazonContender B
Single-ingredient beef chews that buy 20+ minutes of blissed-out silence — the gold standard of edible chews, priced accordingly.
~$30 typical price
Buy on AmazonOur verdict
A durable nylon chew versus a fully edible one — they solve different problems. The Benebone lasts weeks to months, costs a few dollars a month in practice, and satisfies daily gnawing, but nothing comes off it and it must be retired as it wears. A bully stick is single-ingredient, fully digestible, and buys you the most focused 20–40 minutes a chew can — at per-stick prices and with real calories. Most chew-driven households end up with both: nylon for daily maintenance, bully sticks as the special-occasion sitter.
Pick the Benebone if…
- ✓You want one purchase that handles months of daily chewing
- ✓Calories matter — a small dog can't afford frequent edible chews
- ✓Your dog needs an always-available legal chew to protect the furniture
Pick the Best Bully Sticks if…
- ✓You want fully edible and digestible, nothing synthetic
- ✓You need a guaranteed 20+ minute occupier for guests, calls, or crate time
- ✓Your dog ignores nylon but goes feral for the real thing
Spec by spec
| Spec | Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew (Small, Bacon) | Best Bully Sticks 6-Inch All-Natural Bully Sticks |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 8.7 / 10 | 8.7 / 10 |
| Size | Small — about 4.7 in wide, for dogs under 30 lb (Tiny through Giant available) | — |
| Material | Durable nylon infused with real bacon | — |
| Toy type | Long-lasting inedible chew | — |
| Flavor | Bacon (also chicken and peanut butter) | — |
| Edible | No — replace when significantly worn | — |
| Chewer level | Moderate to strong chewers with healthy teeth | — |
| Made in | USA, with US-sourced ingredients | — |
| Supervision | Recommended, as with any hard chew | Required — remove the final nub |
| Length | — | 6 in (4 in and 12 in also sold) |
| Thickness | — | Standard (thin and jumbo cuts available) |
| Ingredients | — | 100% beef pizzle — single ingredient |
| Calories | — | Roughly 15–20 kcal per inch; treat a 6-in stick as ~90+ kcal |
| Digestibility | — | Fully digestible (unlike rawhide) |
| Sourcing | — | Free-range, grass-fed beef |
| Chew time (small dog) | — | About 20–40 minutes per stick |
| Storage | — | Cool and dry; no refrigeration needed |
Still deciding?
Read the full reviews for the complete story, or check both current prices — sale pricing swings this class of decision all the time.
~$13 typical price
Buy on Amazon~$30 typical price
Buy on Amazon